Parliament of Australia · House of Representatives · 25 November 2025
Motions: Dissent from Ruling
Voting yes meant dissenting from the Speaker's ruling, which would have overturned that decision; the motion was defeated.
Defeated41 yes 96 no
The question put
That the ruling be dissented from.
How each party voted
- LaborAll no0 yes · 90 no
90 members
- NoAli France
- NoAlice Jordan-Baird
- NoAlison Byrnes
- NoAmanda Rishworth
- NoAndrew Charlton
- NoAndrew Giles
- NoAndrew Leigh
- NoAnika Wells
- NoAnne Aly
- NoAnne Stanley
- NoAnne Urquhart
- NoAnthony Albanese
- NoAsh Ambihaipahar
- NoBasem Abdo
- NoCarina Garland
- NoCarol Berry
- NoCassandra Fernando
- NoCatherine King
- NoChris Bowen
- NoClaire Clutterham
- NoClare O'Neil
- NoDan Repacholi
- NoDaniel Mulino
- NoDavid Moncrieff
- NoDavid Smith
- NoEd Husic
- NoEmma Comer
- NoEmma McBride
- NoFiona Phillips
- NoGabriel Ng
- NoGed Kearney
- NoGordon Reid
- NoJason Clare
- NoJerome Laxale
- NoJess Teesdale
- NoJim Chalmers
- NoJo Briskey
- NoJoanne Ryan
- NoJodie Belyea
- NoJosh Burns
- NoJosh Wilson
- NoJulian Hill
- NoJulie Collins
- NoJulie-Ann Campbell
- NoJustine Elliot
- NoKara Cook
- NoKate Thwaites
- NoKristy McBain
- NoLibby Coker
- NoLouise Miller-Frost
- NoLuke Gosling
- NoMadeleine King
- NoMadonna Jarrett
- NoMark Butler
- NoMark Dreyfus
- NoMary Doyle
- NoMatt Burnell
- NoMatt Gregg
- NoMatt Keogh
- NoMatt Smith
- NoMatt Thistlethwaite
- NoMeryl Swanson
- NoMichelle Rowland
- NoMike Freelander
- NoPat Conroy
- NoPatrick Gorman
- NoPeter Khalil
- NoRebecca White
- NoRenee Coffey
- NoRichard Marles
- NoRob Mitchell
- NoRowan Holzberger
- NoSally Sitou
- NoSam Lim
- NoSam Rae
- NoSarah Witty
- NoSharon Claydon
- NoShayne Neumann
- NoSteve Georganas
- NoSusan Templeman
- NoTania Lawrence
- NoTanya Plibersek
- NoTim Watts
- NoTom French
- NoTony Burke
- NoTony Zappia
- NoTracey Roberts
- NoTrish Cook
- NoZaneta Mascarenhas
- NoZhi Soon
- LiberalAll yes16 yes · 0 no
16 members
- YesAaron Violi
- YesAlex Hawke
- YesAngus Taylor
- YesBen Small
- YesDan Tehan
- YesJason Wood
- YesJulian Leeser
- YesMary Aldred
- YesMelissa McIntosh
- YesMelissa Price
- YesRick Wilson
- YesSimon Kennedy
- YesTim Wilson
- YesTom Venning
- YesTony Pasin
- YesZoe McKenzie
- LNPAll yes15 yes · 0 no
15 members
- NationalsAll yes8 yes · 0 no
8 members
- IndependentAll no0 yes · 6 no
6 members
Smaller parties and independents
- YesBarnaby JoyceOne Nation
- YesSussan Penelope LeyParty not recorded
Members who didn't vote (absent, paired or in the chair) aren't listed. A party votes as one when at least three quarters of its members vote together.
Source: Hansard, Parliament of Australia, read through the OpenAustralia Foundation's public Hansard data. The summary is AI-written from the question and the bill's official summary, then checked; the record above is the authority.